Requisites

Portraits at The Penthouse – Live in Seattle ~ Bill Evans –| By Eddie Carter

I was still in a mindset to hear another pianist-led release after listening to Mal Waldron, so I chose a Bill Evans album that has become a favorite in my household. Portraits at The Penthouse: Live in Seattle (Resonance Records HLP-2979) is the 8th album reissued by the Bill Evans estate and captures the pianist and his trio in performance over two May nights. The program consists of eight originals and two standards. Sharing the spotlight with Bill Evans are Eddie Gomez on bass and Joe Hunt on drums. The copy I own is the 2025 U.S. Record Store Day, Deluxe Edition, Limited Edition, mono audiophile pressing. Number 1849 of 5000.

The trio’s introduction welcomes the audience into the Penthouse’s intimate atmosphere. They then begin the first night’s set with a lively rendition of How My Heart Sings by Earl Zindars, the title tune from Bill’s 1964 release. Bill steps up first after the opening chorus for a jaunty statement, with an almost dance-like resilience. Eddie takes over, showing how he can build an outstanding solo, while Joe provides excellent support behind them into the reprise and close. ’Round Midnight by Thelonious Monk, Bernie Hanighen and Cootie Williams is one of jazz’s most beloved and recorded standards. The trio honors the classic by beginning the theme that gently glows like embers in a hearth. Evans opens with a graceful solo, radiating warmth and charm. Gomez responds with a tender, heartfelt statement, leading to a beautiful conclusion.

Up next is Come Rain or Come Shine by Harold Arlen and Johnny Mercer, which begins with Bill’s solo introduction, segueing into the ensemble’s medium melody. Bill gets things off to a good start in the opening statement with an infectious swing. Eddie comes in next and conveys his message with authority, preceding the trio’s theme restatement and soft climax. The second night’s set gets underway with Nardis by Miles Davis, and the trio begins by cruising comfortably on the opening melody. Eddie kicks off the opening solo with a lengthy, leisurely walk that swings easily. Bill comes in next and dines on a splendid performance, leading to the theme reprise and soft finale that receives a warm ovation from the club audience.

Earl Zindars’ second contribution to the album is his beautiful ballad, Elsa, which first appeared on “Explorations.” Bill has the stage to himself for the introduction, ahead of the lovely opening ensemble. Evans sets things in motion with a lyrical solo that builds to an effective climax. Eddie follows with one of his most thoughtfully sensuous interpretations, and Bill brings the trio back to the ending theme with a few final thoughts. The second side starts with Bill’s gorgeous introduction to Time Remembered by Bill Evans. The trio’s melody gets things going before stepping aside for Bill’s opening solo that gradually shifts from a gentle, understated mood to a livelier one. Eddie steps in next with a tender reading, until the groups return to the ending theme, with approving applause from the crowd.

Who Can I Turn To? by Leslie Bricusse and Anthony Newley debuted in the 1965 Broadway musical, “The Roar of the Greasepaint – The Smell of the Crowd.” Bill’s solo introduction adds emotional depth, leading to the trio’s lightly swinging theme. Eddie sets the tone with a wonderfully delicate interpretation, then Bill rolls ahead in the following solo before the trio’s closing chorus ends the song on a good note. The beat slows down again for Bill’s tender introduction to Detour Ahead by Lou Carter, Herb Ellis, and Johnny Frigo. The lightly swinging pace picks up for the group’s theme. Eddie is up first and walks with a lively bounce that’s easy to listen to. Bill then effectively illustrates a few melodic ideas, leading back to the out-chorus and the crowd’s approval.

A sprightly piano introduction by Evans sets the tone for Autumn Leaves by Jacques Prévert, Johnny Mercer, and Joseph Kosma. The trio’s melody dresses up this old favorite for Eddie’s opening statement, shared with Joe’s spirited brushwork. Bill follows with a short solo that sizzles with exhilaration ahead of the theme’s restatement and ovation from the audience. The ensemble’s theme returns, a bright-tempoed rendition of How My Heart Sings by Earl Zindars, beginning with a lively opening chorus. Bill leads the way in the first of two solos, and his first swings with scintillating skillfulness, matched by the steady support of Eddie and Joe. Eddie follows with energetic exuberance on the second statement, then the pianist cooks on a vigorously spicy comment before the group takes it out.

I Should Care by Sammy Cahn, Alex Stordahl, and Paul Weston brings the album to a close with a fun tune from the first few notes of the trio’s brisk theme. Eddie has the solo spotlight to himself in a happy, effervescent performance, which flows efficiently to the out-chorus and a very fulfilling finish. Zak Shelby-Szyszko was the album’s production manager. Zev Feldman produced Portraits at The Penthouse for release. Charlie Puzzo, Jr., and Zak Shelby-Szyszko were the associate producers. George Klabin was the executive producer, and Jim Wilke was the engineer. Matthew Lutthans mastered the album. It’s a good recording, but not perfect. The piano tends to be somewhat subdued and less forward in the mix compared to the bass. Occasionally, tape is noticeable, though it doesn’t persist throughout the album.

The record was pressed on 180-gram vinyl in a deluxe-edition gatefold and transferred from the original master tapes. Also included in this album is a 16-page booklet with rare photos by David Azoze and others, plus interviews with Joe Hunt, Eddie Gomez, and Bob James. Even though a few tracks may not have perfect sound quality, fans of Bill Evans seeking relaxing music after a busy day or week will find Portraits at The Penthouse to be an enjoyable live album with comforting moments and musical gems you’re sure to enjoy!

~ Explorations (Riverside RLP 351/RLP 9351), How My Heart Sings (Riverside RM 473/RS 9473) – Source: Discogs.com Autumn Leaves, Come Rain or Come Shine, I Should Care, ‘Round Midnight – Source: Jazz Standards.com ~ Detour Ahead, Nardis, Time Remembered, Who Can I Turn To? – Source: Wikipedia.org © 2026 by Edward Thomas Carter

More Posts: ,,,,,,,,

© Notorious Jazz 2026